Having brought up by someone who had formal education of Islam, I have had the luxury of asking questions about everything my young logical mind can’t accept. Truthfully, I don’t know the details of my father’s education, work, etc and only roughly know bits and pieces of it – the things that he had told me before.
My father lived in Makkah since he was of secondary school age, excelled at the University of Al-Azhar with a first class honours degree and emerged as the best international student when he was there. He did his Ph.D in Scotland, (if I’m not mistaken in Islamic Civilization), whom his tutor back then was not even a muslim, but recited and understood the Quran more than a muslim does. Completing Ph.D in the early 70s was tough without the internet, he even had to go to Vatican City himself to get a copy of a document for his research. He speaks flawless arabic, and one of the things I loved to do back then was eavesdrop when he was talking the language with his friends, eventhough I did not understand almost all of it.
At times I do wonder why my father was not as strict as some of his friends who was in the same field. I wasn’t asked to put on the hijab until I wanted to. I remembered I am still allowed to hold the Quran without wudhu’. I was allowed to participate in school performances. I can wear what other youngsters wore at that time. Things that most people in our community felt it was wrong to do, especially if one’s dad was an ustaz, or someone that’s supposed to be religious. When I got the only B in my PMR for islamic studies, he just laughed it off, and had no shame when his friends asked him. Obviously to him, B is just on paper. What’s built up inside (faith) is more important. I guess his experiences, his surroundings, the people he gained knowledge from, made him the man he was.
Now that I’m a grown up and have a son as curious as I am, I am slowly starting to understand. These things do come with reasons. Like I’m allowed to hold the Quran without wudhu’ – it is good to be able to do so, but it is not compulsary. I have to agree with this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGBornAuY3Y. Good explanation, and to me, if it is made compulsary, and someone wants to read it on the way to work on the LRT for example, I’m sure it’ll just stop him from doing so – because he doesn’t have wudhu’! As for participating in school performances, way of dressing, donning the hijab – I believe he wanted me to experience life as everyone else did, whilst slowly telling me what is required in Islam, as the after-effect of being deprived would be worse, I’m sure. Besides, anything done drastically will only have a short term effect, right?
Trust me, my mind unintentionally became so active as it is now. Just because the boy comes up with unthinkable questions every so often, I had to come up with my own version of unthinkable questions too!
I do notice there is a difference in the way of teaching when someone is well-versed and have done numerous years of research about Islam, compare to those who only learnt a little and considered themselves qualified. Those who knows little tend to be more rigid, and gives illogical reasoning and focuses more on the things that we can actually do without. I have heard so many different opinions lately and it triggered a lot of questions on a lot of issues. At this point of time, I chose to just continue what I have learnt, believed and practiced since young and at the same time do more readings and gather as much information as I can.
And yes, this made me miss him even more. Especially now when I need so much guidance to answer my own curious mind and also the little ones’ challenging questions.

p.s. The boy asked me the other day why he needs to wash certain parts of his body (wudhu’) to solat, when he’s already clean n just stepped out of the shower. I had to google to find the best answer for him!